More on Teacher Evals

I posted this at today in response to Brian Hubbell’s piece entitled Two Circumstances: Legislature’s Education Agenda.  Brian is one of the clearest thinkers I know on the subject of education in Maine.  He is passionate about protecting public education, but doesn’t hesitate to carefully consider alternate points of view even if they conflict with his own. Teacher evaluations are something I feel passionate about, so here’s what I said:

I disagree with Brian’s characterization of teacher evaluations as “mere”, at least as they apply to individual teachers across the state.  Whether or not performance pay is ever implemented in Maine, the impact of a teacher evaluation model that includes student performance for even a short period of time could have long-term consequences for teachers who are early in their careers.

10 or 20 years down the road, when Paul LePage and the 125th Legislature are long gone, the evaluations done during this period will still be in teachers’ personnel files.  Having been in the situation (as a union representative for teachers), I know full well that superintendents will go back into those files to try and find a pattern of poor teaching in order to dismiss, non-renew or  otherwise force a teacher out.

By then, few will remember that the teacher-evaluation-based-on-student-performance was just a phase.  And for those that do, the fact that the teachers’ own union was part of the group approving the evaluation model will be a strong argument in favor of using the individual evaluation against the teacher in question.

Since there isn’t much money available, as Brian correctly points out, so-called merit pay schemes are unlikely to find much traction in the Legislature.  But a teacher evaluation process that includes student performance is well on its way to implementation.  I can only trust that someone will speak persuasively on behalf of the thousands of Maine teachers who will be affected by the decision before it is a done deal.



Filed under Education in Maine, MEA

3 responses to “More on Teacher Evals

  1. munjoy fan

    The law prohibiting the use of student achievement data for teacher evaluation or promotion in Maine was enacted in 1984 during the move to create local teacher support systems. It was a key MEA achievement at the time. Apparently it has been repealed. This opens the door to all kinds of mischief, with or without legislative action. Does anyone know what the MEA obtained in return for giving up this valuable law?

  2. Pingback: Labor Management Collaboration in Maine | edumaine

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s